There's a way cryptocurrency businesses can get around New York's notoriously hard-to-get BitLicense, and it runs through Wyoming.
At least, so say members of the team that drafted the 13 crypto-friendly laws enacted by the Western state this year. One of those laws allows Wyoming to charter Special Purpose Depository Institutions (SPDIs), a new type of fully-reserved fiat bank that can also custody crypto assets.
With an SPDI, crypto exchanges and other startups could operate in New York without going through the state's licensing rigmarole, under the same legal principles that exempt banks from needing state money transmitter licenses, Wyoming advocates said.
"We are fairly confident that the Wyoming SPDI will be able to operate in New York without a BitLicense," Chris Land, general counsel of the Wyoming Division of Banking, said Tuesday at CoinDesk's Invest: NYC event in New York.
The New York Department of Financial Services (NYDFS), which created the BitLicense in 2014, did not answer requests for comment by press time.
The BitLicense was one of the earliest regulations specially crafted for the blockchain industry. But many firms have complained that it is onerous and has driven entrepreneurs and innovators away from New York, the U.S. financial capital.
Only 18 BitLicenses have been granted in the rule's five years of existence. Getting hold of one is known to be a slow and expensive process, and that's if you are in full compliance with all the requirements, which amount to a heavy-duty version of a money transmitter license. Some companies that fell short of NYDFS' expectations have publicly bemoaned the process.
In addition to addressing the BitLicense problem, an SPDI could ease a longstanding pain point for crypto businesses: the difficulty of obtaining banking services.
Once approved for the charter (the statutory minimum capital requirement to apply is $5 million), firms would have master accounts with the Federal Reserve and the own ability to clear their own wires.
In other words, they could literally be their own banks, to use a familiar motif from crypto-land.
"Some companies might choose to partner with unaffiliated SPDIs and others might choose to create their own affiliated SPDI," Caitlin Long, the gubernatorial appointee to the Wyoming Blockchain Task Force, told CoinDesk.
"The significance is that crypto companies won’t need to rely anymore on the few traditional banks that have been willing to bank the industry," she said.
The handful of crypto-friendly banks in the U.S. includes Silvergate in California and Signature and Metropolitan Commercial in New York. Long said one of the best-known of these banks (she wouldn't say which one) employs 65 compliance officers, making the whole business very expensive.
If the Wyoming SPDI works out as suggested, it could be seen as an interesting parallel to the way Citi found a clever way to sidestep New York's tough usury laws. The bank made a landmark decision in 1981 to move its credit card operation to South Dakota, where legislators were won over by Citicorp's promise of jobs if that state lifted its usury ceiling.
And as part of the "far-reaching impact" of the SPDI, Long said she is optimistic the NYDFS will view the bank charter as trumping the BitLicense since banks have higher capital and regulatory requirements than money transmitters do.
"The Wyoming SPDI would need to apply to NYDFS to open a branch in New York and NYDFS would need to approve the application, but there’s a lot of favorable case law precedent," said Long, a former Morgan Stanley executive. "So if NYDFS denies the application, I think it would go to litigation and the Wyoming bank would likely prevail."
Long also sounded optimistic about lawyering up if need be. After she spoke alongside Land on Tuesday's panel, she said, "multiple New York attorneys came up to volunteer pro bono to help the Wyoming Banking Division litigate if it ever comes to that."
From left: Caitlin Long, Chris Land, Mary Beth Buchanan of Kraken and Anette Nazareth of Davis Polk at Invest: NYC 2019, image via CoinDesk archives
The leader in news and information on cryptocurrency, digital assets and the future of money, CoinDesk is a media outlet that strives for the highest journalistic standards and abides by a strict set of editorial policies. CoinDesk is an independent operating subsidiary of Digital Currency Group, which invests in cryptocurrencies and blockchain startups. As part of their compensation, certain CoinDesk employees, including editorial employees, may receive exposure to DCG equity in the form of stock appreciation rights, which vest over a multi-year period. CoinDesk journalists are not allowed to purchase stock outright in DCG.
Learn more about Consensus 2023, CoinDesk’s longest-running and most influential event that brings together all sides of crypto, blockchain and Web3. Head to consensus.coindesk.com to register and buy your pass now.